I've stayed at the hotel at Nanny Cay for years, usually for a couple of nights upon arrival and a night upon departure. As has been mentioned before, there aren't too many options there - Captain Mulligan's and Peg Legs for dinner, Gennakers and coffee shop for breakfast and lunch. The pool is nice, the beach is somewhat small and unimpressive. I like the hotel because of the price and proximity to the boatyard and docks.

If you have a rental car then things are much better. And a rental with 4WD that can mount "the elevator" means you can reach locations on the north side that much quicker.