Do both kids need their own cabin?

You could try the Lipari 41 cat -- has a 3-cabin version - Capt Jay has one at CYOA I believe as does BVI Yacht Charters - reviews on them are quite good as to how they sail. We have a 4-cabin version for our May charter. It will give you a comparison. I say give the cat a try. I still prefer monos but why not check it out? It's just a charter....