Thank you everyone. I should not have been so direct in my question. I realize no one can make the decision except my family.

Each of you, however, has taken the time to help us understand the implications of our decision by sharing your personal knowledge of hurricanes, tropical storms, and St. Martin itself. For that, we greatly appreciate your kindness and information sharing.

We have been to St. Martin twice for day stops on cruise lines. So we have minimal understanding of the beautiful island. We are/were (still not decided) so thrilled to see the island for a full week. We have only a few more hours to sweat the decision....but if you have further perspective or thoughts, we'd truly appreciate your information.