I think there's potential for a number of issues. And unless you really need your dog, such as a service dog, I don't think it is worth the various potential risks. While I know our dog would have fun, our dog will ultimately be fine at home and safe. I've read of issues with paperwork being incorrect, missing or some other issue and that causing a variety of issues. I just think it isn't worth the risk for a vacation. A service dog is a completely different situation and I imagine treated differently - and certainly from the sounds of it, welcomed, where I think a regular dog might not be as welcome.

Elsewhere is a whole other story since there are even more requirements. I've ready plenty on traveling with dogs to various islands and some are easy, some are not so easy. None seem worth the hassle for a vacation. Living aboard is again another story.