Yes Club O is gone ,for now, and the beach in front of the property is still and likely will be forever clothing optional. The Perch is gone but Cedrick and some other former Club O staff have built a replacement called Perch Lite. They have a full bar, a decent menu and a restroom and all reports are its all pretty good. They also rent the classic loungers and umbrellas you probably remember. There are several good options for accomadations as mentioned. We choose Mt Vernon this time for its location, right on Orient as well as price. Depending on your transportation needs car rental usually ends up being more of an expense than advertised and definatly a hassle. We use a local guy,Winston Blythe. There are many reports that the island traffic has gotten quite bad so Im happy to let a seasoned local deal with that. Good luck and enjoy ! Cheers.