I have chartered with Sunsail (multiple), BVIYC (multiple), Dream (once - most recent - Hodges Creek), Captains Compass (three times - 1x fat hog, 2x old one)) since Irmaria.

A few benefits of DYC. Price. Charters any day (ie, will do Tuesday to Tuesday for example), Easy from EIS with two big grocery stores on the way, Not the best base, but not the worst I have used either.

A few negatives - we also had a service call, resulted in different boat (big upgrade) which was nice, but we only had 3. Other than that, they were pretty great.

I will use them again. But when I do I use Samboat to book it. You get the discount still, but have a 3rd party to do the dirty work for you if something goes wrong.