Totally agree on the two(or three) nights..this island is a rare gem to be enjoyed at a casual pace..its far different than any other Virgins ( 28 feet about sea level)and that may turn some folks off/...island rules..book your restaurant with meal choices before 4 .We all have our favorities ..for me favorite beach Cow Wreck..restaurants, Wonky Dog, Sids and the Lobster Trap ( owned by the Anegada Beach Club folks..great food there too).Rent your car from Dean..