We flew from Aguadilla to Anegada during an island hopping trip in 1992 in a Piper Archer. (I would not do this now in my “old” age - lol). The Anegada Reef hotel was THE place. Rum Smoothies were the drink. The Wheatleys were running it then as they still are today. It was idyllic. Wish I could recapture that feeling of being at the end of the world surrounded by the intense beauty of that water with so very few people around. It feels mobbed up there now by comparison. 😎