As my brother-in-law says (who's a mechanic and sells used cars), "There's an [censored] for every seat".

Everyone has different reasons for liking certain stops. For us, Anegada is nice, but we like to dive and you can't dive from the boat there. My recommendation for two nights at Leverick (aside from being a great way to spend time) was based on it being your honeymoon. Driving to the Baths and exploring other sites as well as having a nice meal out at Coco Maya or other spots is a great change from the typical dinghy trip you tend to always take.

I'd suggest looking at the suggestions, looking at the cruising guide and knowing what your fiance likes, base your itinerary on that. Just remember weather can change it all.